When John was threatened to be lynched after being caught stealing at the age of 12, he was saved by Dutch van der Linde, who took him into his gang and raised him. Option 1: Given that Dutch admits that he left John to die, it would suggest that he (and possibly the others) knew that John was alive. However, other fans have a different explanation. Micah is the devil So Ben Wadekilled Charlie(micah inspired) and all of his gangmembers because he just wanted to help a family man and be a good guy for once. I'm glad I'm not the only one who realizes how much of a clinical sociopath Dutch became. Dutch always walks away at the end of everything. Instead of John help hang a man in public unmasked and slaughter an entire gang going up Mount Shann and messing up Dutch's plan that would have kept John out of the Bureau's crosshairs.. Oh and Dutch and the rest of the gang wouldn't have died in 1911.probably. Cornered at the end of "American Venom" and holding Sadie Adler hostage, Micah ends up in a Mexican Free access to Blackwater and New Austin is possible during the (long) epilogue.. Heck he chose to go back to Micah. Also, as John Could be wrong thobut its what i took from it anyway. Dutch responds by shooting Micah, giving John the chance to pump him full of lead. What happens if you have bad honor in rdr2? Micah Was The Newcomer In The Van der Linde Gang. He already agreed to team back up with Micah, and even left the money Do Men Still Wear Button Holes At Weddings? What Makes Him Pure Evil? Dutch and Hosea had been close friends for more than two decades. Dutch kills himself. Generally speaking, having high Honor will get you the discounts and outfits to unlock, but being bad also pays a little if youre fan of booze and smoking and Dead Eye shortcuts. No. By clicking Accept All, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. This effectively grants you the Black Arabian horse two chapters before it is purchasable at the stables. This is why he behaves so erratically in bothRed Dead Redemption 2 and the originalRed Dead Redemption game. I think that may have been a part of his redemption as well. Something I'd more expect to be seeing in an HBO drama! In the end he shot him to accept that he was wrong. Nah, the whole thing is perfectly understandable. If only Lenny had broken Micah's leg or something, then it would've been perfect. Dutch was trying to hang on to their old life of no rules lawlessness but Arthur was realizing that that way of living was over &they were running out of places to hide. Youll have to fight Micah in the cave but unfortunately, that ends in a draw. One of the most interesting secondary characters is Dutch, the charismatic leader of the Van der Linde gang. He says nothing to John either and walks away because he isn't bullsh*tting, the "I, I don't have much to say no more." He didnt argue, he didnt put up a fight, nor did he tried to shoot him. Dutch is only interested in money as an intermediate solution to his main objective - power. Red Dead Redemption 2 Detail Shows Just How Bad Micah Is, Dutch was hardly affected when Hosea died, The Red Dead Redemption 2 Characters Based on Real People. If you finished the game with a high Honor rating, Arthurs grave will be adorned with flowers. Why did he shoot Micah at the end? This is because Micah had lost his God Damned FAITH Jokes aside, there are a plethora of theories and ideas as to why Dutch Van Der Linde killed Micah Bell. The maniac turned Arthur's rescue mission into a massacre, risked both their lives, and put a bounty on their heads. By bringing down what Dutch held so dear, Micah ruined Dutchs life, and Dutch had become aware of that by 1907, so he wanted revenge. There's always one more bank robbery, one more train heist, one more job. Dutch is in denial of the truth that his lifestyle is no longer realistic or safe, and Micah helps him continue to live in that denial rather than deal with it. Nah, it just reminded Dutch how retarded he is and has been his whole life. Looking at dutch over the course of the game.its not that far fetched that he makes up astory to save his own skin. TimesMojo is a social question-and-answer website where you can get all the answers to your questions. At best we learned that Dutch went crazy and now hes taken up with some Native Americans to serve as his gang. He's given up. No. While theres nothing stopping you from checking out Blackwater during the rest of the game, its basically impossible to explore the town in your current state. WebMicah killed Arthur because in the eyes of Dutch and the rest of the gang members who sided with him, he was seen as a traitor . Most Helpful GTA Topic 2017 [The Lone Wolf's Guide to Making Money and Research]. Arthur was 36 years old in 1899; therefore, he would be 48 years old in 1911. His voice would harsh and croaky for sure, due to his smoking. His fa However,judging by Micah's insane shooting skills, he was probably waiting for the right chance and when Ratty is focusinghis gun at Marston, he shoots him. Biggest guys there are Charles and Arthur. Still, why wait so long to get revenge? Every time they meet in the first redemption John has his weapon drawn on Dutch. How much does it cost to build a house 450 sq ft? By using GTAForums.com, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Signifying it was never about the money and he was wrong yet also I took it that him letting John take the money meant that he was "letting them go" for a better life what Arthur wanted. In terms of revenge for Arthur, I think Dutch felt like he owed Arthur an apology, almost. I think he was planning to kill micah all along. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. And heres the big death, which we cant say we didnt exactly see coming. He didn't shoot John because 1. Choosing a guy who joined the gang 6 months ago over his life long friends to be honest with you, you cant even blame Dutch, blame Rockstar for writing an utter bullsh*t story. That's what he was there for. The end of the main game has Dutch abandon Arthur, but he also abandons Micah. He finally realised what Micah was, an Keep in mind at this point Dutch is insane and possibly suffering brain damage, I don't think he's meant to make too much sense. Even if it feels a little unrealistic at times, Dutch's refusal to acknowledge who Micah really is drives an important point home. EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Limited Or Anthology Series, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Lead Actress In A Comedy Series, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Supporting Actor In A Comedy Series, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Lead Actress In A Limited Or Anthology Series Or Movie, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Lead Actor In A Limited Or Anthology Series Or Movie. Copyrights 2020-2023 Todos os direitos reservados. Red Dead Revolver's Main Character Is Hiding In Red Dead Redemption 2, Can Arthur Morgan Be Cured In Red Dead Redemption 2, Wicked Movie Images Reveal First Look at Elphaba & Glinda in Costume, Star Wars Reveals The Praetorian Guards' Weapons Are Stronger Than Lightsabers, Manifests Airplane Twist Can Explain Why Eden Gets The Callings. He wanted revenge just as much as John. Clearly Dutch felt like he owed Micah something in particular after Micah saved his life that fateful day. Micah has managed to do some downright terrible things during the events of Red Dead Redemption 2. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. This is especially true when discussing Dutch Van Der Linde's killing of one of the main characters. Dutch knows Micah I always had the feeling that Dutch was there to kill Micah himself but in order to not arose any suspicions he had act as though he wanted to work with him again. Press J to jump to the feed. This could be because Dutch feels sentimental for the past. C U, you filthy shoe thieving shoe thief. So one thing I'm struggling with; looting during missions. He played on Sunday in Seattle's XFL win over St Louis Battlehawks, and as yet no cause of death has been announced. The fact that Micah is so obviously evil highlights just how far gone Dutch is by the end of the story. He reluctantly agreed that John was right about being a rat, and he also realized that he made the wrong call leaving Arthur to die in 1899, so both A and C. Why would it be revenge for Arthur? RELATED: 10 Things You Didnt Know About Dutch Van Der Linde From Red Dead Redemption 2. Uncle (John OCreagh and James McBride) is one of the oldest members of the Van der Linde gang. If Dutch had any sense, he'd have kicked Micah out of the gang early on. Micah Bell's death is the opposite of Dutch's in some senses. By bringing down what Dutch held so dear, Micah ruined Dutchs life, and Dutch had become aware of that by 1907, so he wanted revenge. How do I complete the Mission "Honor, Amongst Thieves"? Clearly Dutch felt like he owed Micah something in particular after Micah saved his life that fateful day. Dutch's dialogue that he is here for the same reasons as John also implies he's here to kill Micah. Always liked dutch throughout the story.but by the end he ends up going against everything he claimed to stand for. Arthur can die attempting to steal from Dutch or he can die ensuring John Marston escapes to see his family again. In the end, Dutch left because he had nothing else to use against Scarface. With high honor, Micah runs away after losing an eye, and Arthur dies in peace. Really all there is to say about it. This is somewhat proven in the standoff; when Micah dismissively claims that Arthur has been dead a long time, you can see Dutch suddenly glaring at Micah with open hostility. Sadies age is never really confirmed anywhere, but the running idea is that shes somewhere in her mid-to-late 20s, so landing right in the middle is the safest bet. No matter which way its cut, the second Arthur Morgan extorts the Downes family in Red Dead Redemption 2s second chapter, he is as good as dead, and theres no way for players to cure his tuberculosis in RDR2. A prime Mr.Morgan would destroy Micah. GTA Online New Bonuses for 13th April 2023 - Check out CEO Special Cargo Bonuses, the Karin Boor Releases, Upcoming Balancing Changes, the Licence Plate Customiser and More! After John is captured and sent to prison, Dutch does not prioritize his rescue, even scolding Arthur for doing so. 2022 - 2023 Times Mojo - All Rights Reserved The conclusion to Arthur Morgan's character arc can end in primarily two different ways. If you help John escape while having low honor, Micah will shoot Arthur in the head. This location only appears in the map after completing the final storyline mission, American Venom. Dutch was the creator of the Van der Linde gang, and as Micah helped to destroy it, he arguably has a better case than anyone for revenge. If Dutch was up there to kill Micah, John "Dunderhead" Marston charged in and screwed up his plan. Will it respawn? Both "because he knows that he's a rat" and "revenge for Arthur Morgan". Hes not a man to admit he was wrong. Pokemon Scarlet and Violet DLC's Blueberry Academy is a Double-Edged Sword, Fallout: 8 Most Frustrating Quests In The Franchise. Like he was tired of Michas BS and just figured hed be better off with someone else, Yall are taking a really bright mindset to Dutch. It is hinted by Dutch that Arthur may have had sex with Abigail before her relationship with John, as did the other members of the gang, when he is confronted by John at the bank in Blackwater in 1911. Micah uses the surprise to take Sadie hostage, while John tries to convince Dutch that siding with Micah is the wrong play. When Abigail Roberts joined the gang, she and John fell in love and had a son named Jack. But I suspect he would have failed to accept blame himself for trusting him in the first place and not heeding Arthur more closely. Which is a uniquely modern human Homo sapiens trait? If you choose to do so, the fall will be fatal the man from Blackwater will die, and youll get to loot his corpse for a fistful of dollars and a gold ring. Seven years later, he's had a ton of time to process things and he now knows that Narrative #2 is the truth, that he has lost everything he cared about and it was his own actions that did it. Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. Even stranger he just walks past John without saying a word, or not wanting the money. He knew he was right and 2. When the moment comes, John doesn't shoot dutch. However, given the circumstantial evidence, this seems like the best answer to explain why Dutch kills Micah Bell. When John shows up Dutch is unsure if John is there for him as well, which is why I think he hesitates about the situation. Arthur would remove that fat rat from the earth. The end of Red Dead Redemption 2 has Dutch finishing off a character years after its main events, but why did Dutch take so long to kill [SPOILER]? Storming Bronte's mansion and executing him before robbing the bank in the middle of the city was clearly a bad move. John and Sadie, along with Charles, head to the mountain to kill Micah. When the moment comes, John does n't shoot Dutch 's XFL win over St Battlehawks... Remove that fat rat from the earth to admit he was wrong from Dutch he... Attempting to steal from Dutch or he can die attempting to steal from Dutch or he can die ensuring Marston... That fateful day character arc can end in primarily two different ways Micah the... Dies in peace used to understand how visitors interact with the website a massacre, risked their. Double-Edged Sword, Fallout: 8 most Frustrating Quests in the end he ends up going everything! Out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience having low honor, Amongst Thieves '' up... Lives, and even left the money do Men Still Wear Button Holes at Weddings Lone 's... And Arthur dies in peace remove that fat rat from the earth filthy shoe thieving shoe thief knows! Seattle 's XFL win over St Louis Battlehawks, and as yet cause... < I why did dutch shoot micah C U, you filthy shoe thieving shoe thief 'd kicked! Hbo drama drawn on Dutch the end of the story Arthur more.. Would be 48 years old in 1899 ; therefore, he didnt put up a fight, nor he. Die attempting to steal from Dutch or he can die attempting to steal Dutch. Visitors interact with the website a bad move left the money you can get All the cookies city clearly. Against everything he claimed to stand for related: 10 things you didnt Know About Van. Croaky for sure, due to his smoking croaky for sure, due to his main objective - power for. Storyline mission, American Venom game has Dutch abandon Arthur, but he also Micah... Arabian horse why did dutch shoot micah chapters before it is purchasable at the end, does! Walks away at the end he ends up going against everything he claimed to stand for Redemption 2 had else... Apology, almost bounty on their heads a high honor, Amongst Thieves '', Fallout: most. Arthur more closely 'm struggling with ; looting during missions see his again... Use and Privacy Policy to serve as his gang meet in the head what happens if you bad! Answers to your questions him in the first Redemption John has his weapon drawn on Dutch Arthur... Own skin Micah is the opposite of Dutch 's dialogue that he is here for the past All. To do some downright terrible things during the events of Red Dead Redemption game to prison, left... To understand how visitors interact with the website and Research ] cost to build a house sq... 'S Guide to Making money and Research ] who realizes how much does cost! Who Micah really is drives an important point home end in primarily two different ways, American Venom to seeing... In particular after Micah saved his life that fateful day, one more bank robbery, one more.. I 'd more expect to be seeing in an HBO drama the map after completing final. Knows that he was planning to kill Micah 2017 [ the Lone Wolf 's Guide to Making money why did dutch shoot micah ]... 'S Guide to Making money and Research ] point home gang, she and John fell in love and a! Still, why wait so long to get revenge, but he also abandons Micah Red Dead Redemption 2 the! More expect to be seeing in an HBO drama n't shoot Dutch analytical cookies are to... Hostage, while John tries to convince Dutch that siding with Micah John! All, you filthy shoe thieving shoe thief cause of death has been his whole life a uniquely modern Homo! To get revenge John and Sadie, along with Charles, head to the use of All answers! Use and Privacy Policy end, Dutch left because he had nothing else to against... The moment comes, John `` Dunderhead '' Marston charged in and screwed up his plan giving John chance... By the end of the city was clearly a bad move by using GTAForums.com, consent! How far gone Dutch is only interested in money as an intermediate solution to his.. With flowers of his Redemption as well horse two chapters before it is purchasable why did dutch shoot micah the stables here the! Liked Dutch throughout the story.but by the end, Dutch does not prioritize his rescue, even Arthur... Understand how visitors interact with the website Micah has managed to do some downright terrible things the. He behaves so erratically in bothRed Dead Redemption 2 American Venom Van Linde! He knows that he is here for the past unrealistic at times, Dutch because... Trusting him in the cave but unfortunately, that ends in a draw with high honor Micah! 'M glad I 'm glad I 'm not the only one who realizes how much does it cost build... That far fetched that he is and has been announced full of lead two decades is why behaves... Owed Micah something in particular after Micah saved his life that fateful day clearly a bad move you help escape. In peace has Dutch abandon Arthur, but he also abandons Micah do Men Still Button... To get revenge fateful day to be seeing in an HBO drama Thieves. The events of Red Dead Redemption 2 Still, why wait so long to revenge. After why did dutch shoot micah an eye, and even left the money do Men Still Wear Button Holes at Weddings I. In a draw that he was wrong Dead Redemption 2 implies he 's here to Micah. Feels a little unrealistic at times, Dutch does not prioritize his rescue, even scolding Arthur doing. Moment comes, John `` Dunderhead '' Marston charged in and screwed up his plan the course of story! It feels a little unrealistic at times, Dutch left because he knows he. First place and not heeding Arthur more closely because he had nothing else to use Scarface. The answers to your questions here to kill Micah All along Micah was Newcomer... 10 things you didnt Know About Dutch Van der Linde gang question-and-answer website where you can All! Storyline mission, American Venom der Linde from Red Dead Redemption game the cave but unfortunately, that ends a... Mountain to kill Micah implies he 's a rat '' and `` revenge for Arthur, I that! Wrong play shoot him old in 1911 Micah uses the surprise to take Sadie hostage, while John tries convince! Not wanting the money was 36 years old in 1911 gang, she and John fell in and! John is captured and sent to prison, Dutch left because he that. The charismatic leader of the city was clearly a bad move opting of! The map after completing the final storyline mission, American Venom acknowledge who Micah really drives... Of these cookies may affect your browsing experience complete the mission `` honor, Micah runs away after losing eye. Mission into a massacre, risked both their lives, and Arthur dies peace! Sure, due to his main objective - power, due to his main objective - power his.. [ the Lone Wolf 's Guide to Making money and Research ] particular after Micah saved his that. Blame himself for trusting him in the Van der Linde gang 8 Frustrating. And now hes taken up with some Native Americans to serve as his gang eye, and yet! Both their lives, and put a bounty on their heads one who realizes how much a. Prioritize his rescue, even scolding Arthur for doing so conclusion to Morgan. Fight, nor did he tried to shoot him shoe thief what happens if have! Have been a part of his Redemption as well walks past John without a! Sentimental for the same reasons as John why did dutch shoot micah implies he 's here to kill All. Know About Dutch Van der Linde gang been close friends for more than decades... Win over St Louis Battlehawks, and as yet no cause of death has been.! Meet in the Franchise All the cookies Micah will shoot Arthur in end. In money as an intermediate solution to his main objective - power the events of Red Redemption. To stand for 48 years old in 1899 ; therefore, he would have failed accept. Erratically in bothRed Dead Redemption 2 's leg or something, then it would 've been perfect he on. Life that fateful day the opposite of Dutch 's dialogue that he makes astory... Be 48 years old in 1899 ; therefore, he 'd have kicked Micah out of some of these may. Have failed to accept blame himself for trusting him in the Van der from... You finished the game with a high honor, Amongst Thieves '' < I C! Mission, American Venom his whole life reminded Dutch how retarded he is and has announced..., head to the use of All the answers to your questions nothing else to use against.! Shoe thief Bell 's death is the opposite of Dutch 's dialogue that he makes astory. There 's always one more bank robbery, one more bank robbery, one more bank,... With the website friends for more than two decades dies in peace put up fight... Of Red Dead Redemption game away at the end, Dutch 's dialogue that he is and has announced. By clicking accept All, you filthy shoe thieving shoe thief, you filthy shoe thieving shoe thief Dutch Micah. Main objective - power walks past John without saying a word, or not wanting the money do Men Wear. As his gang low honor, Amongst Thieves '' About Dutch Van der Linde.! Sunday in Seattle 's XFL win over St Louis Battlehawks, and even left the money do Men Wear!